Casting Crazy Amy
Crazy Amy Crazy Amy
- Steven John Cena
- Noam Dave Attel
- Norman Norman Lloyd
- Donald Ezra Miller
- The Dogwalker Daniel Radcliffe
- The Dog Owner Marisa Tomei
- Schultz Jon Glaser
- Bryson Randall Park
- Allister Evan Brinkman
- Dr. Conner's Patient Pete Davidson
- Tim Tim Meadows
- Kyle Kyle Dunnigan
- Himself Amar'e Stoudemire
- Himself Matthew Broderick
- Himself Marv Albert
- Angry Subway Patron Leslie Jones
- Temembe Method Man
- S'nuff Receptionist Kim Caramele
- Staten Island Oli Josh Segarra
- Lisa Nikki Glaser
- Kat Bridget Everett
- Chris Evert Chris Evert
- Woman on Bench with One-Hitter Lisa K. Price
- Gordon's Friend (uncredited) Tommy Bayiokos
- Benefit Guest (uncredited) Jessica Cherniak
- Amy's son (uncredited) Henry Gagliardi